1985-1990: Basilica of Our Lady of Victory, Lackawanna, NY
1992-1998: St. John the Baptist Church, Kenmore, NY
1999-2000: All Saints Church, Buffalo, NY
2001-2003: St. John the Baptist Church, West Valley, NY
2004: Retired (P.O. Box 2082, Blasdell, NY 14219)
2005-2011: Retired (34 Birchwood Ave., Apt. 6, West Seneca, NY 14224)
2012-2016: Retired (540 Birchwood St., Apt. 3, West Seneca, NY 14224)
Notes: On March 20, 2018, the Diocese of Buffalo included Fr. Thomas J. McCarthy on its list of priests who have been accused of child sexual abuse. The diocese did not disclose any information regarding the allegations, Fr. McCarthy’s prior assignments, or his current location. As of 2016, Fr. McCarthy was believed to be a retired priest residing in West Seneca, New York.