Michigan AG Report Exposes Decades of Clergy Abuse Allegations in the Diocese of Grand Rapids
In December of 2025, Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel released a long-awaited public report detailing decades of allegations of sexual abuse and misconduct committed by clergy in the Diocese of Grand Rapids. This report is the fifth in a series covering Michigan’s seven Catholic dioceses, part of a broad investigation that began in 2018 in partnership with the Michigan State Police:
- Diocese of Marquette Report | October 2022
- Diocese of Gaylord | January 2024
- Diocese of Kalamazoo | May 2024
- Diocese of Lansing | December 2024
Breakdown of Clergy Identified in the Diocese of Grand Rapids Report
51 priests have been identified in the Diocese of Grand Rapids Report. Of these 51 priests, 38 were ordained or incardinated by the Diocese of Grand Rapids. This information was compiled from materials obtained through a search warrant executed on the Diocese of Grand Rapids in October of 2018, and from the tipline operated by the Department of the Attorney General since 2018.
Of the 51 priests identified in this report, 30 are not linked to prior public lists and are newly identified:
Fr. Rock James Badgerow
Fr. Lawrence Dannemiller
Fr. Michael Gormley, C.M.
Fr. Martin James Hoogterp
Fr. John Whalen Patrick McGee
Fr. Edward O’Connor, C.Ss.R.
Fr. Malcolm Andrée Portée, S.C.J.
Fr. Reinhard J. Sternemann, O.S.A.
Fr. Richard John Van Lente
Fr. Albert Lambertus Watson
Fr. Daniel Arnold Cook
Fr. Harold Rudolph Feltman
Msgr. Joseph Walter Grill
Fr. Edward J. Kubiak
Fr. Edward Joseph Mike
Fr. Peter Omogo
Msgr. Joseph E. Shaw
Fr. Donn Patrick Tufts
Fr. Frederick J. Voss
Msgr. Herman Henry Zerfas
Fr. Dennis Cooney, O.M.I.
Fr. Isidro Tabay Gargantiel
Fr. John Raphael Hadnagy, O.F.M. Conv.
Msgr. Arthur La Rue
Fr. Denis P. Nash
Fr. Theophilus Palukaitis
Fr. Edward Statkus
Fr. Marcel Alphonse Vanbergen
Fr. William Paul Walters
Of the 51 included in the report, 21 have been previously identified by the Diocese of Grand Rapids, Bishop-Accountability.org, or other Diocesan/Archdiocesan lists:
Fr. Daniel Aerts
Fr. Stanislaus Bur
Fr. John Thomas Sullivan
Fr. Shamaun Beas
Fr. David LeBlanc
Fr. Joseph Kenshol
Fr. January Padlo, O.F.M.
Fr. Eugene Alvesteffer
Fr. Donald Heydens
Fr. Dennis Wagner
Fr. William Langlois
Fr. Michael McKenna
Fr. Richard Barry, O.M.I.
Fr. James Thiel, C.Ss.R.
Fr. Louis Baudone
Fr. Lawrence Hartwig
Fr. Charles Antekeier
Fr. Richard Lawie
Fr. Richard Host
Fr. Benedict Marciulionis
Fr. Theodore Tsiakalos
Why Has the Diocese of Grand Rapids Not Released a List of Credibly Accused Clergy?
The Attorney General’s report shows that the Diocese’s public disclosures have been incomplete, delayed, and insufficient for decades. While the Diocese has acknowledged some allegations in limited ways over time, the data demonstrates that government investigation, not voluntary transparency, has been the primary mechanism for public accountability.
What This Means for Survivors and the Community
The release of the Diocese of Grand Rapids report follows similar releases for other dioceses across Michigan and reflects years of investigative work. While legal action against many accused clergy may no longer be possible, the report serves several crucial purposes:
- Acknowledgment of survivors’ experiences
- Public documentation of historical misconduct
- Encouragement for others to come forward
- A reminder of the importance of accountability and institutional transparency
The Diocese of Grand Rapids has long evaded transparency. It is only through the courage of survivors and the intervention of the Attorney General’s office that the public now has a clearer picture of the scope of abuse. Of the 51 clergy members identified, only a fraction had ever been publicly acknowledged by the Diocese, while roughly 30 names emerged for the first time through law enforcement records and survivor reports.
Although many of these cases cannot be prosecuted due to the passage of time, death, or legal limitations, that reality does not erase the harm or the public’s right to know. For many survivors, whose stories may never be heard in a courtroom, public acknowledgment may be the only form of accountability left.
If you or someone you know has experienced clergy abuse, you are not alone, and it is not too late to come forward. Survivors can contact the Michigan Attorney General’s clergy abuse tipline or seek confidential legal and advocacy support to understand their rights and options. Public accountability begins when survivors are believed, institutions are honest, and silence is no longer tolerated.
Disclaimer: This report is for informational purposes only. It is a compilation of excerpts from the information obtained from the tipline, victim interviews, police investigations, open-source media, paper documents seized from the Diocese of Grand Rapids, and the electronic documents found on the diocesan computers, as well as reports of allegations disclosed by the diocese.
This report contains detailed descriptions of allegations of sexual abuse or assault and other sexual misconduct (including grooming and misuse of authority), by priests or deacons who are current or former clergy for the Diocese of Grand Rapids, that occurred in the Diocese from January 1, 1950, to the present. The Diocese of Grand Rapids was established on May 19, 1882. Should you need assistance, please call 855-VOICES4.
A criminal charge is merely an allegation, and a defendant is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.